Book Reviews Information

Critical Condition: How Health Care In America Became Big Business-And Bad Medicine:


Title: Critical Condition: How Health Care In America Became Big Business-And Bad Medicine:

Authors: Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele

ISBN: 038550453

The following review was contributed by:NORM GOLDMAN: Editor of Bookpleasures:

REVIEW

Investigative reporters and the only journalists in history to be awarded two Pulitzer Prizes and two National Magazine Awards, Donald L. Barlett and James B. Steele have presented a riveting exposé of the critical state of the health system in the United States with their book Critical Condition: How Health Care In America Became Big Business-And Bad Medicine.

Beginning with the assertion that American health care has been transposed from one of compassion to a system motivated by profit- the authors present a distressing analysis as to what went wrong. Where forty-four million citizens do not have health insurance, and tens of millions more are underinsured. And yet there seems to be this enduring myth propagated by many that the USA has a "world- class health system."

As mentioned by the authors, the USA spends more on health care than any other nation, when you compare it to Germany, France, Japan, Italy, and Canada. However, in these countries citizens do not think twice about seeking care if they are ill. They do not worry who will foot the bills.

In the USA, it has become a lottery. If you are fortunate to be employed by a large company providing generous health benefits, you win. On the other hand, if you are self-employed or work for a small enterprise providing little or no coverage, you lose. You may even go bankrupt and lose your home in order to pay your medical bills.

Relying on interviews, studies from various organizations as the World Health Organization, the US department of Health and Human Services, legal suits, brokerage reports, congressional hearings, newspaper articles, magazine stories, SEC filings, professional journals, and a resevoir of many other sources (all of which are mentioned in the Notes section at the back of the book), the authors deliver legitimate arguments illustrating how an assortment of factors have crawled into the system with calamitous effects.

Broken down into six chapters, Barlett and Steele judiciously examine some of these elements as: rampant overcharging of patients who do not have insurance, dissuading people from purchasing drugs from Canada with false information concerning the Canadian pharmaceutical industry, caving into the demands of special interest groups, the non-existence of independent monitoring of diagnostic test results and hospital mistakes, permitting politicians and business people to assume key roles to the detriment of the welfare of the citizens, a culture of cronyism giving rise to blatant fraud in many instances, doctors having to deal with conditions apt to be found in undeveloped countries, peopled shuffled around by individuals who do not have the foggiest notion as to how to deal with them.

In addition, we are informed of how private enterprises connected with Wall Street financiers and Madison Avenue advertising firms have been permitted to join in as if health care was analogous to the selling of cars or MacDonald's franchises. As the authors rightfully ask: "Is this what health care in America has become?"

Although the authors portray a certain amount of cynicism, there is a glimmer of hope, as evidenced by the concluding chapter, wherein suggestions are offered as to how to revamp the ailing system.

However, the question lingers on. Will Americans reconsider their values, priorities, budgets and options and elect people, who will first and foremost take care of its citizens when it comes to health care? Something most civilized nations do.

Norm Goldman is Editor of the book reviewing site, http://www.bookpleasures.com and the travel site, http://www.sketchandtravel.com.

Norm is also a regular contributor to many book reviewing sites.You can read Norm's book reviews on his book reviewing site bookpleasures.com.

Norm and his artist wife Lily are a unique husband and wife team who meld art with words focusuing on unique romantic and wedding destinations. To learn more about them click on their site at http://www.sketchandtravel.com


MORE RESOURCES:

Study: Readers trust amateur book reviews as much expert book reviews
WTOP
A study from the Harvard Business School says when it comes to book reviews, readers trust each other as much as they trust the so-called experts. The study's authors found that online reviewers at sites like Amazon.com were usually kinder to new ...

and more »


The Guardian

The battle of the book reviews
The Guardian
Is the professional book reviewer an anachronism? In a recent Harvard Business School study of nonfiction reviews, assessments in mainstream media outlets like this one and amateur ratings on Amazon largely converged. Assuming we can trust the ...
Amazon consumer book reviews as reliable as media expertsTODAYonline
Everybody's an Expert, or, 1972 Amazon Reviewers Can't Be WrongMobyLives
How A Tennessee Wife And Mother Of 4 Became A Top-Rated Book CriticForbes
Digitaltrends.com -The Verge
all 16 news articles »


Critical eye: book reviews roundup
The Guardian
Kate Summerscale and Hilary Mantel both won major prizes and enjoyed spectacular sales figures with their previous books – the Samuel Johnson winner The Suspicions of Mr Whicher and the Booker winner Wolf Hall, respectively – and they happened to ...

and more »


Publishers Weekly

San Francisco and Sacramento Book Reviews Start Monthly Children's Sections
Publishers Weekly
Heidi Komlofske, president and CEO of the four-year-old book reviews, says that in the past the publications would partner with local schools to have children review books for the yearly features. “That didn't work, though,” she says, “because the ...



Mizzima News

Book reviews: The Burmese economy
Mizzima News
–Koichi Fujita, Fumiharu Mieno, and Ikuko Okamoto, eds., The Economic Transition in Myanmar after 1988: Market Economy versus State Control. Singapore and Kyoto: NUS Press in association with Kyoto University Press, 2009. Books about Burma's economy ...



The Atlantic

Could the Internet Save Book Reviews?
The Atlantic
His idea to review only the best books didn't spark a revolution in 1946 and probably won't start one any time soon, but the essay points to the fact that book reviews haven't changed very much in the past 65 years—until now.
Confessions of (Another) Book ReviewerTIME

all 2 news articles »


Book reviews | 'Louisville Murder and Mayhem' and 'The Axman Came from Hell'
The Courier-Journal
By Keven McQueen. The History Press. 111 pp.; $17.99 By Keven McQueen. Pelican Publishing. 240 pp.; $17.95 With these two winning books, Keven McQueen, a teacher at Eastern Kentucky University, has combined impeccable research with a clear love of the ...

and more »


The Atlantic

Book Reviews: A Tortured History
The Atlantic
One popular complaint is that book reviews are merely a byproduct of the publishing industry and therefore stink of mediocrity, elitism, nepotism, or all three. In 1846, Poe wrote that book reviews (and the publishing industry) were a sham and riddled ...



Book Reviews: Transcending the Natural
Dallas Baptist Standard
By Staff, Baptist Standard Whether you seek a nonfiction narrative or a Bible study, Transcending the Natural meets your needs. The opening story captures the reader's attention. Bill Lawson describes how traveling to play golf altered his life.



Book Reviews: The 100 Greatest Ever Golfers; Two Good Rounds
Golf.com
By Gary Van Sickle, Senior Writer, Sports Illustrated You may not be aware that someone other than Hank Haney has written a golf book in the last three months, but it's true. Here are two more light-hearted alternatives to the inside story of ...


Google News

home | site map
© 2006